So... Has anyone ever given/received a creampie surprise?
I'm not proud of this one, but here goes...
I met a girl online and drove to her house to hookup. She was... Out of my league, to say the least, even though I feel pretty confident in myself. Tall, skinny, brunette, and more confident than me. When I was texting her that I arrived, she told me to go through the backyard gate and come around. I felt a little weird about it, wondering if it was too good to be true, but I did so.
She was in the jacuzzi next to her swimming pool, and I was awkward meeting her for a moment, because I was never told to bring a bathing suit. She just laughed and said "join me naked", and she turned a bit and stood up to wring her hair out, giving me a view of sideboob. I did as she asked and started to get in with her... It was cold, and I was hoping she wasn't looking, because I'm definitely a grower-not-a-shower... She totally was, and didn't look disappointed, so either she picked up on that or didn't care.
She suddenly got a little awkward too and cuddled into me, taking my hand and moving it to feel her tits. I started kissing her neck and she reached down to start playing with my junk... I got hard for her right away. She sort of got on top of me, her ass against my cock, and I played with her tits from behind... They were probably b cup, but that was totally ok with me.
Then she balanced herself and bent over for me. I started getting on top of her, having to grab the edge because I slipped. I think she was trying to initiate more foreplay, but I really, really wanted her. I was fully aware that the condoms in my pants pocket outside the hot tub were neither in reach nor useful in the water. I didn't care at the moment, I wanted to fuck her.
It was hard getting inside... She was so, so tight and small down there that my thick tip wouldn't even go in. After her help and some maneuvering, I was inside. I started pounding into her from behind, and it felt really good... It was far from the best fit for my cock, but it was pussy and it was amazing. I was just watching the way she arched her back and picking up the pace... Getting more and more into it.
We'd hardly gone at it for a minute when I felt myself getting close. I was really inexperienced at the time, and it was embarrassing to not be able to keep up. I slowed down considerably and squeezed her tits from behind, telling her she was so sexy... I was trying to bide my time and recover, but it wasn't working. She was so fucking sexy that I was going to cum whether I liked it or not.
I really wanted to cum inside her, but I knew it was potentially risky and I was so embarrassed. To be fair, we had talked dirty over messages, and one thing I mentioned was filling her with my cum, but it was in passing with other dirty suggestions, and she didn't give it any reaction in particular. Having this in mind, I ended up giving in.
I felt my orgasm build and I picked up the pace considerably. I bit my tongue as I kept thrusting, determined not to give myself away, as I started cumming inside her even as I fucked her. I can't describe how it felt, because deep down to my dirty inside, I wanted to knock her up just because she was beautiful, and I just kept going, never intending to tell her.
She truly did not seem to notice.
I, however, needed a moment to recover and felt myself deflating as I was thrusting. Luckily, I think I lasted longer after cumming than before, and I think I shoved it far enough inside that she didn't know. I pretended to lose my balance off the edge and blamed that.
After that, we moved to some lounge chairs put together and started making out for a bit. She was playing with me, and I was taking annoyingly long to get hard again, but I blamed the cold air. Once I was ready, I got on top of her and started fucking her again. This time, we went at it for a little while. Halfway through, she told me she wanted to suck my cock and swallow my cum. As she was stroking it, I asked "So... since I've at least been inside you, are you on the pill or something?". She laughed and told me she had an arm implant. She sucked me to completion as I pleasured her and made her cum on my hand. It wasn't awkward anymore, but once we were finished we agreed to do it again. Neither of us ever ended up reaching out though for a bit, and once I did, she didn't live there anymore.
